Some products can be described by reading a label, while others ask to be tasted. Extra virgin olive oil belongs to the second category. To truly get to know it, we need to pause for a moment, recognise its aroma, follow its flavour and listen to what it tells us about the place it comes from.

Every olive oil is the result of many choices: the variety of olives, the season, the timing of the harvest, processing and storage. Even two harvests from the same grove can offer different nuances. This is one of the things that makes extra virgin olive oil as familiar in our kitchens as it is surprising when we give it a mindful tasting.

At Case Luparello, this story begins among the olive trees of our Sicilian estate. Simply calling our product a good local oil is not enough for us: we want to explain what words such as fruitiness, bitterness, pungency and balance mean, and show how these characteristics have also been assessed through a professional sensory examination.

The character of an extra virgin olive oil cannot be measured with a single adjective. It is recognised in the relationship between the aromas of the olives, the sensations in the mouth and the persistence after tasting.

From grove to bottle: flavour begins with the land

Our grove has over a thousand trees planted around forty years ago. They are part of the agricultural history of Case Luparello and set the rhythm of the estate: the growth of the olives, their changes as they ripen and the arrival of harvest time.

A good extra virgin olive oil does not come from an unchanging formula. Climatic conditions, the condition of the olives and processing methods influence the product’s profile. Cold mechanical extraction is one characteristic of our oil, but on its own it is not a sufficient guarantee of quality: everything that happens before and after processing matters too.

This is why we are interested in telling the whole story, from the fruit to the tasting. When we know where an oil comes from, its sensations also become easier to understand.

An oil should have personality without overpowering the dish

An extra virgin olive oil with a recognisable profile does not necessarily have to be the most intense. It needs to express itself. Sometimes it subtly accompanies the ingredients; at other times it adds a green contrast, a bitter note or a livelier finish.

That is why balance does not mean a lack of character. It means that fruitiness, bitterness and pungency can coexist in a coherent whole. None of these attributes, taken alone, is enough to describe the entire oil.

The most direct way to notice this is to taste it on its own first, then uncooked on a simple food: a slice of bread, seasonal vegetables or a pulse soup. Comparing the two experiences reveals how much oil can change the final result of a recipe.

Sensations first, numbers second: the panel test

Expressions such as “fruity” and “balanced” should not be mere advertising phrases. In the sensory analysis of olive oil they have a technical meaning, defined by specific assessment methods.

To explore our product’s profile, a sample of Case Luparello oil from batch 1G323 underwent a professional sensory assessment on 10 December 2024 at CAPOL in Latina. Test report no. 51/2024 describes a balanced oil with medium green fruitiness, medium bitterness and medium pungency.

The profile of the analysed sample

Fruitiness: 4.4 — median intensity of fruitiness, classified as green.

Bitterness: 4.0 — a positive attribute of medium intensity.

Pungency: 4.9 — a pungent sensation of medium intensity.

Median of defects: 0.0 — the value recorded by the panel for sensory defects.

Source: CAPOL Latina, test report no. 51/2024. The results describe only the sample from batch 1G323 examined on 10 December 2024, not subsequent production.

Green fruitiness: the aroma that comes before tasting

The word “fruity” can be misleading. It does not necessarily indicate a sweet taste or the aroma of ripe fruit. In professional tasting language, it describes the characteristic olfactory sensations of oil obtained from healthy, fresh olives.

In the Case Luparello sample examined, the panel identified green fruitiness of medium intensity. This classification refers to an overall fresh, green sensation, without attributing individual aromatic notes to the sample that the report does not specify.

We can begin to recognise this component at home too. Pour a small amount of oil into a glass, warm it briefly with the palm of your hand and bring it to your nose. Before looking for technical terms, simply ask what impression it leaves: fresh, green, intense, delicate?

It is a simple exercise, but it changes how we perceive an ingredient we often use without pausing to notice its qualities.

Bitterness and pungency: two often misunderstood qualities

In everyday life we readily associate bitterness with something unpleasant and pungency with an overly strong flavour. In extra virgin olive oil, however, bitterness and pungency are positive sensory attributes. They can vary in intensity and help define its personality.

In the analysed sample, bitterness reached 4.0 and pungency 4.9. These are medium-intensity values, with pungency slightly more pronounced than bitterness.

During tasting, bitterness is perceived mainly in the mouth; pungency may appear as a tingling sensation at the back of the mouth or in the throat. It should not be confused with free acidity, which is a chemical parameter and cannot be judged by that tingling.

Naturally, this does not mean that the more bitter or pungent an oil is, the better it will be. Quality is not a competition in intensity. The point is to understand the relationship between the different sensations and recognise any defects.

What does a median of defects of zero mean?

The report’s results also include a value of 0.0 for the median of defects. It may sound less evocative than the aroma of olives, but it is essential to understanding a sensory assessment.

Alongside positive attributes, the panel test looks for sensory defects. A median of defects of zero indicates that, under the method used, the sample does not have a positive median for the defects assessed. When fruitiness and the conditions required by the method are present, this result is consistent with the sensory classification of extra virgin.

The CAPOL report classified the examined sample as extra virgin olive oil. It is important to distinguish this result, referring to a specific sample, from the chemical and physical checks that form another part of the overall assessment of the commercial category.

Where does the oil’s character express itself best?

Tasting oil on its own helps us understand its main sensations. But oil is also about cooking, and its personality reveals itself when it meets ingredients.

A profile with medium green fruitiness, bitterness and pungency can go well with rustic bread, bruschetta, grilled vegetables, pulses and soups. Added uncooked just before serving, its aromatic components are generally easier to appreciate.

Our suggestion is to try the same dish with different oils. A chickpea soup or a simple slice of bread can become a small tasting laboratory: changing the oil is enough to reveal new nuances.

A document to consult, not simply to quote

We chose to make the sensory report public because we prefer to accompany our descriptions with verifiable data. The document does not replace personal tasting, but it helps explain the technical basis for the description of the analysed sample.

The report gives the batch, date, test method and recorded values. Anyone who wishes to explore further can read it in full, without having to rely solely on the words of our presentation.

Read the CAPOL test report

One clarification remains essential: the sensory profile can change from one harvest year to another. The December 2024 results are a documented reference for the batch examined, not a promise that every bottle produced in the future will have exactly the same values.

Getting to know oil where it is made: the Case Luparello experience

We like oil to be more than a description on a web page. On our Sicilian estate, among the olive trees, we also offer olive oil tastings by reservation: an opportunity to become familiar with its sensory language and discover the relationship between agriculture and the local area.

Those wishing to extend the experience can stay in our apartments, Biancolilla, Moresca, Carolea and Coratina, each named after an olive variety. The estate also offers a beautiful infinity pool surrounded by greenery, allowing you to enjoy the Sicilian countryside as a place to relax too.

This meeting of hospitality and agricultural production embodies the most tangible meaning of our project: being able to observe the trees, get to know the product and then find a part of that same landscape at the table.

Discover Case Luparello extra virgin olive oil

Would you like to know the available sizes, buy our oil or book a tasting? We will be happy to give you all the information. And if you would like to discover its place of origin in person, you can choose to stay among the olive trees on our estate.

Our extra virgin olive oilContact usDiscover the apartments

Because an oil can be described with numbers. But to truly get to know it, you need to taste it and know the land it comes from.